Skip to main content

Halloween Sugar Cookies

These Halloween Sugar Cookies are sweet, not spooky.
Image placeholder title

Halloween kicks off the unofficial sugar cookie season. It’s true! Halloween sugar cookies are likely the first batch you’ve made since Easter. I’m right aren’t I?

Maybe you’re the mom that is happy as a clam to fire up the oven to bust out a batch of July 4th sugar cookies. But I’m not. I’m the mom that’s going to snip off the top of the Otter Pop and call it a day.

Image placeholder title

But something magical happens when the weather gets cooler and the days get shorter—it means that it’s time to start considering warm and hearty meals and afternoons spent in a warm kitchen making memories and baked goods.

Yes, while I’m firmly Team Popsicle all summer long, I’m also Nostalgia Mom during the holidays—always looking for ways to create some seasonal traditions for my kiddos.

Image placeholder title

This Halloween Sugar Cookie recipe comes from April’s kitchen and is a HUGE hit. The cookies are foolproof and aren’t too sweet, so they are PERFECT for generous coat of buttercream frosting and sprinkles.

So break out your Halloween cookie cutters—we’re partial to bats, ghosts, and pumpkins—stock up on sprinkles and candies, and go wild! Tis the season, after all.

Halloween Sugar Cookies Recipe

1 cup butter

1 cup sugar

2 eggs

1 cup sour cream

1 tsp vanilla

1/2 tsp baking soda

4 tsp baking powder

5 1/2 cups flour

1/2 tsp salt

Cream the butter and sugar, adding the eggs one at a time. Add the remaining ingredients until well blended. Wrap dough in plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least 1 hour (or overnight). Roll out and cut into shapes. Bake at 350°F for 8-10 minutes (depending on thickness). Makes 4 dozen small cookies.

Image placeholder title

Halloween Sugar Cookies with Black Cocoa Variation

Want to try a dark yet still sweet variation? Try replacing a ½ cup of flour with ½ cup of black cocoa to add an extra spooky twist to this Halloween sugar cookie recipe. 

Black Cocoa Sugar Cookies

We’re thrilled to share these two Halloween sugar cookie recipes. Adding black cocoa powder to this recipe is one of our favorite variations. 

halloween sugar cookies

Don’t worry about doing anything different. Simply add the black cocoa powder where you would originally add the ½ cup of flour. Bada bing. Bada boom. 

black cocoa halloween sugar cookies
Scroll to Continue

Recommended for You

Take a peek at our Christmas Sugar Cookies and our our sweet Valentine’s Sugar Cookies for more sugar cookie ideas.

Want to get cracking on your Halloween baking? Here are a few of our FAVORITE accessories!

Image placeholder title

Fred GingerDEAD Man (Hilarious)

Image placeholder title

Is it a Ghost, or is it a Tulip! (Both. It’s both.)

Image placeholder title

Spider Cookie Cutter (Creepy, but delicious.)

Image placeholder title

Halloween Cookie Cutters (One of each!)

Image placeholder title

Jumbo Candy Eyes (I keep these around, year-round.)

Image placeholder title

Another Candy Eye Option (You can never have too many.)

Image placeholder title

Halloween Sprinkles (We use these on pancakes, hot cocoa, really anything that will stand still.)

Happy Baking!


Basic Sugar Cookie Hearts

Basic Sugar Cookie Recipe

Don't have time for a batch of sugar cookies? Skip a step with this Basic Sugar Cookie Recipe. You'll be ready to frost in a jiffy!

Image placeholder title

Sugar Cookie Madness

4th of July is done, and as our grill is cooling off, I sit munching on the extra sugar cookie bars.

7 MORE Sugar Cookie Recipes

7 MORE Holiday Sugar Cookie Recipes

MORE sugar cookie recipes? Bring it!

9 Sugar Cookie Holiday Recipes

9 Sugar Cookie Holiday Recipes

Sugar cookies. It doesn't get better. TRULY.

Image placeholder title

The Perfect Sugar Cookies

My mother stole this recipe from my piano teacher years ago and it has become a favorite in our family.

best cranberry orange cookie recipe

Cranberry Orange Cake Mix Cookies

Our Cranberry Orange Cake Mix Cookies are fast and easy enough to be an everyday cookie, and fancy enough for your next party. Citrusy orange, the zing of dried cranberries, and just enough glaze on top to bring the whole thing together.

Sugar Cookie Bars

Sugar Cookie Bars

It's time to bring back some deliciousness from the archives! Looking for something wonderful to take to your next spring family gathering (or maybe just something to tame your sweet tooth)? Check out these amazing sugar cookie bars!