Stop Forcing the “Sorry”: A Better Way to Teach Kids to Repair

If you’ve ever demanded an apology just to end the chaos—“Say sorry to your sister right now!”—you’re in good company. Most parents do it. But according to psychologist Dr. Lisa Damour, author and co-host of The Ask Lisa Podcast, forcing apologies rarely teaches kids what we actually want them to learn from apologizing.

“If it’s extracted, it’s not real,” Dr. Damour says.

That performative “sorry” might stop the fight for a minute, but it doesn’t build empathy, repair the relationship, or teach self-awareness. In fact, it often fuels resentment and sibling rivalry—especially if one child feels Mom or Dad is “taking sides” instead of focusing on teaching kids to apologize sincerely.

---

Why Forced Apologies Backfire

Dr. Damour points out that kids usually interpret a forced apology as punishment, not connection. This perception impedes the process of teaching them to apologize sincerely.

“You’re sending the message that you’ve crossed a line,” she says, “but you may also open up a new gate of trouble—now you’re on one child’s team.”

When kids see apologies as something adults make them do, they don’t internalize the lesson. Instead, they focus on compliance (“Just say sorry so we can move on”) rather than accountability (“I hurt someone, and I want to fix it”). This doesn’t help in genuinely teaching kids to apologize.

---

A Better Way to Handle Conflict

So what should parents do instead? Dr. Damour suggests separating two key moments: stopping the behavior and teaching repair.

1. Stop the behavior firmly, without lecturing.
   A simple, calm “Knock it off” works better than a long explanation in the heat of the moment. It halts escalation and keeps you out of the sibling tug-of-war while opening the door for teaching kids to apologize later.
2. Circle back later when emotions have cooled.
   When things are calm, Dr. Damour suggests asking: “Do you know why I asked you to stop?” or “Do you understand what wasn’t okay?” This reflection helps your child process why their behavior crossed a line—and what empathy looks like in action. This approach also aids in the process of teaching kids to genuinely apologize.
3. Ask how they plan to fix it. “What are you going to do to make it right?”
   It might be saying sorry, drawing a picture, or offering to help with something. The key is that they come up with it, so it’s genuine.

---

From Punishment to Repair

Parents often confuse discipline with punishment. But as Dr. Damour notes, real discipline means teaching—not just consequences. This is crucial when teaching kids to meaningfully apologize.

“Anytime we’re punishing a kid, what we’re really hoping is that they figure out how to fix it,” she says.

When you shift from “Who’s to blame?” to “How can we repair this?”, you’re modeling emotional intelligence. Kids learn that relationships are worth mending and that mistakes are part of growth, an essential aspect of teaching kids to apologize effectively.

---

The Long View: Raising Empathetic Kids

The goal isn’t perfect peace—it’s resilience and empathy. As Dr. Damour reminds parents, even kids who fight constantly can grow into deeply connected adults.

The real skill to nurture isn’t forced politeness—it’s repair. When kids learn to own their mistakes and make amends sincerely, they carry that emotional toolkit into friendships, classrooms, and eventually, adulthood.

So the next time you’re tempted to say, “Say you’re sorry,” try a pause instead. Knock it off. Cool down. Circle back. And help your child find a way to really make it right, embracing the journey of teaching kids to apologize effectively.

More on TodaysMama.com

9 Best Phrases to Use in an Argument to Stay Calm and In Control

7 Steps to Handle a Relentless Arguer Without Losing Your Mind

3 Ways to Respond When Your Child Says I Hate You