Skip to main content

Is The Grass Greener On The Other Side?

Would I be a better mother if I didn’t work? It’s a question I ponder at least a hundred times a day, while I’m at work.
  • Author:
  • Updated:

Kara Eberle

Smart Mama

Would I be a better mother if I didn’t work?

It’s a question I ponder at least a hundred times a day, while I’m at work.

I wonder if my daughter would be happier and healthier if I spent all day with her.

Then again, I wonder if she would be able to count in Spanish, recite dozens of nursery rhymes or cut in a straight line if she had stayed home with me, instead of going to day care.

The back and forth in my brain has been almost constant lately — because I’m having another baby.


We learned just before Father’s Day that I was pregnant with Eberle No. 2.

Although it was a welcome surprise, this pregnancy has brought up lots of not-so-fond memories from Mara’s infancy.

I went back to work when she was 8 weeks old, working 3 to midnight Tuesday through Saturday.

The first few months were horrible.

I had nursed her, almost exclusively, when I was on maternity leave. The first time she took a bottle from my husband didn’t go well. She wanted me at bedtime. She cried and cried. And so did I.

I don’t even want to think about pumping in the office bathroom each night. The choice to breastfeed after returning to work wasn’t an easy one, but I wanted to do it for my baby.

When I would get home around 1 a.m., Mara was almost always crying. I think she could hear my Jeep pulling into the driveway. Most nights, I would nurse her back to sleep and get to bed around 3 a.m. She would wake up three hours later, ready and raring to go.

My husband, Mark, worked days at the time, so I would be alone, sleep deprived, taking care of our baby until he got home. Then, at 3 p.m. each day, Mark would walk through the door, and I would head to work.

It’s how we survived until Mara was almost 2, when I got a day-shift position, my husband got a second-shift job, and we enrolled her in day care.

While day care has been wonderful in many ways, it hasn’t been a cure-all.

Scroll to Continue

Recommended for You

With conflicting work schedules, it’s harder than you’d think to figure out how to pick up a child before 6 every day.

Plus, it’s expensive. It’s like adding a new-car payment to your monthly budget. A really nice new car.


With another baby on the way, I want to make sure I don’t repeat any mistakes I made the first time around. I want to make sure everything goes as smoothly as possible.

So the question repeats in my head:

Would I be a better mother if I didn’t work?

I wonder what it would be like to make a real dinner for my family during the week, or how it would feel to have clean laundry, folded and put away.

I wonder what it would be like to dust and vacuum on a regular basis, instead of naming the spiders that take up residence in the corners of our stairs.

I do household chores on the weekend or after Mara goes to bed, but it never seems to be enough. And my husband helps out a lot, but there are some things I just like to do myself.

I know that being a stay-at-home mom wouldn’t solve all my problems, and that I would probably miss going to work every day.

Plus, the Eberle Family Budget is based on two incomes, not one. So it’s essential that I remain gainfully employed (until we win the lottery, that is). But, even though I don’t really have a choice, I still worry if I’m doing the right thing.

I just wish I could find the right balance with my work and my family, so that I don’t feel like I’m constantly slighting one, the other or both.

Thankfully, I have a good place to start: a great job that I enjoy at a company filled with supportive co-workers. I also have a wonderful family, and a new baby to be excited about.


As for the question that runs through my head, I don’t know the answer. And it doesn’t matter.

I think it’s pretty normal to have questions. (If it’s not, don’t tell me.)

For now, I will work to find a better balance between my family and my work.

And, I’ll focus on all the awesome aspects of being a mom, rather than dwelling on the memories that make me cringe.

Kara Eberle is editor of Smart, and her second baby is due Feb. 24. Read more Smart Mama columns here.


Time Is Of The Essence

As someone who’s never been a fan of mornings, I know how hard it is to wake up. I also know what it’s like to be jostled awake, against my will, and forced to face the day.

My Daughter’s First Perfect Checkup

My usually bubbly girl stared out the window as I drove up Interstate 83. Her frown spoke volumes. I knew she didn’t want to go to the dentist. She had made that clear in the days leading up to the visit.

Time Stands in the Way

Time can be my best friend and my worst enemy. When Mara wakes me at 4:30 a.m., I’m not a big fan. When I’m rocking on the front porch on a breezy summer afternoon with Mara on my lap, I’m happy for every second.

Sharing The Spotlight

My baby boy is due in a month. Of course, I’m worrying about the little guy’s health, labor and delivery, and how I’m going to lose my baby weight. But I also can’t stop wondering how my daughter is going to adjust to sharing the spotlight.

Smart Mama: On Language

“If you were a dog, Daddy, what dog would you be?” Emma asked recently at dinner. Random questions are popular among the 6-and-under crowd.

The Ultimate Motivator

The arrival of a new baby is quite a motivator.

Waiting For Labor

At 39 weeks pregnant, I can’t think about anything except going into labor. Is it going to happen now? How about now? Maybe now?

Hold On To The Moment

I wonder how much loss aversion influences my parenting. How what I’ve gained slips through my fingers like a minnow, flashing away before I appreciate its beauty, while what I’ve lost crashes like a boulder into still water, rippling through me long after first impact.