Skip to main content

When to Intervene

Books often advise us against intervening, for example, when a child is having a tantrum or siblings are fighting. However, these “blanket rules” for interacting can easily mislead or confuse us.

A friend of mine used to scream Nooo!” when her child fell down. Her screaming was more startling than her child tripping. I often wondered if her daughter adopted the attitude that falling down was a tragic event. As adults, the impulse to “fix” things often makes us react when something goes wrong with a child. Books often advise us against intervening, for example, when a child is having a tantrum or siblings are fighting. However, these “blanket rules” for interacting can easily mislead or confuse us.

It’s more helpful to reflect about intervention and when it supports thoseinvolved and when it undermines their abilities to handle things for themselves. I sometimes find when I watch children to see if children can handle an argument thatsituations resolve themselves. Other times, no response could cause “wrong thinking.” Let’s talk about circumstances that propel us to act and think about our choices.

A child screaming in disappointment or frustration

We can show we understand and accept children’s feelings without trying to talk them out of feeling disappointed or mad.

Siblings hitting each other

We always need to intervene if children are hurting each other. Children should never infer from our non-action that physical aggression is okay. But one person doesn’t have to be wrong. You can help them work out their conflict with words.

A child yelling at another child

Yelling often gets our adrenaline flowing. At another school, I once heard an adult yell at a child who was raising his voice, “Use your words!” However, yelling is using words, and sometimes when children are trying to establish a boundary with someone else, they have to yell. If they said “I was using that first” in a soft voice, they could easily be ignored. As adults, we want to watch two things—whether the person yelling is maintaining self-control and whether the listener is overwhelmed. We could also observe the emotions – “It sounds like you’re angry!”– then ask the other child, “How are you feeling?” We could also offer each compliments for not hitting or name calling (if that’s the case).

If feelings are hurt, we can request that the angry child state her needs in a calmer voice.

Scroll to Continue

Recommended for You

When young children are cooperating on a project, there is often loud talking. Standing back to see if they can communicate often brings wonderful results.

Your colleague or partner or a relative is expressing anger toward a child

It depends. There is a difference between an adult saying “I’m upset that you did that” and yelling in a way that intimidates a child. We want children to learn that they have a different relationship with each person, and people get upset about different things. Sometimes we don’t have to do anything. However, if an adult is losing self-control and belittling a child, we might say, “I understand how you’re feeling. Do you want me to take over for a few minutes?” Often just stating our understanding will defuse the situation. If an adult is swearing at a child, calling him names, or hitting, we would always ask to take over.

Children wrestling or playing shooting games

At school we don’t allow children to wrestle because someone usually gets hurt. Shooting games aren’t allowed at school, though young children show enormous creativity in devising toy guns.However, as we know from our own childhoods, wanting to explore these activities is normal. You can set up your own rules at home but explain to your child that other situations may have different guidelines. This is important because we sometimes find that children who roughhouse at home hurt people unintentionally at school because that’s the way they think people play.

Children saying they are bullied at school

Intervene by talking to your child’s teacher about her perspective on the situation. If your child does feel intimidated by a schoolmate, you can role-play how to speak up or ask your child what ideas he has for handling the situation. The main goal is to help a child feel empowered to respond in situations for herself. There’s a wonderful picture book about a father supporting his son who feels bullied at the playground without telling him exactly what to do, only validating his feelings and asking questions. The intervention we want to avoid is accusing another parent of not disciplining her child or confronting the “intimidating” child ourselves. Children and adults have a whole range of temperaments, and we want children to feel confident and brave interacting with almost anyone.

Child calling a person who isn’t present names while expressing anger to us

We could say, “I understand why you’re angry, and that’s fine. But we have to respect other people by not calling them names.” When we establish the habit of not belittling people whether they are present or not, relationships flow more positively.

Susan Isaacs Kohl, is director of the White Pony preschool in Lafayette. She is the author of The Best Things Parents Do (Conari 2004) and four other books and numerous articles for parents.


Children’s Perspectives on Spanking

It seems especially refreshing for children to live in a place and a time when children would assume a teacher would never physically punish them and feel safe to ask questions so openly.

Playdates Require Sensible Guidelines

We want to ensure that parents use sensible guidelines when allowing their child to visit someone else’s home. We share ideas about this subject because the notion of children needing to have playdates is relatively recent.

Clarifying Rules, Values

Research shows that talking about rules and the reasons why we follow them enhances children’s moral development. The idea isn’t to nudge them into a new stage of abstract thinking but to help them grow into making thoughtful decisions.

Guiding Play Away From Aggression

Batman swoops in, shocking his enemies and knocking them ferociously to the ground. This scene sizzles on screen. However, played out by four-year-old boys eager to feel powerful, it quickly ends in tears.

Look for Upliftment

In times past, parents looked to experts like Dr. Spock or Haim Ginott to inspire them with new ways to relate to children. Today parents who go online or read widely about childrearing can glean insights but also easily feel overwhelmed.

I Thought My Friend Would be in Class This Summer

Most parents don’t subscribe to the “sink or swim” approach today when it comes to water safety—or the variety of other activities they make available to their children.

playing with kids

Really Playing With Kids

Engaging in the themes your child wants to explore creates closeness in your relationship. Those feelings of intimacy fuel your child’s desire to please you and comply with your requests.

Asking the Right Questions

Positive queries lead children (and adults) to pause and think and even call on their highest understanding. As one six-year-old commented, “Sometimes questions help you learn what you already know.”