Giving Children a Voice and a Choice

A few days after starting college, my daughter called to report her distress about her dorm-mates’ apparent immaturity. “They feel uncomfortable making simple decisions about their lives, like choosing their meals every day.”
Publish date:




st1\:*{behavior:url(#ieooui) }

/* Style Definitions */
{mso-style-name:"Table Normal";
mso-padding-alt:0in 5.4pt 0in 5.4pt;
font-family:"Times New Roman";

A few days after starting college, my daughter called to report her distress about her dorm-mates’ apparent immaturity. “They feel uncomfortable making simple decisions about their lives, like choosing their meals every day.” Eighteen is the designated age when we feel young people should be capable of adult decision making. However, most of us aren’t taught decision-making skills growing up. As parents, we also discover that knowing what choices to offer a child at various stages is confusing! A two-year-old asked what he wants for lunch may say cookies, but a four-year-old can make good choices when offered an array of healthy foods. We wouldn’t expect a two-year-old to decide what color to paint her bedroom, but we might consult a nine-year-old on the right shade and even support a teenager in trying to paint her own room.

Over many years, the pendulum has swung toward getting children’s opinions on everything from what they want for breakfast to what house the family should buy. Years ago, world-renowned child therapist and author Haim Ginott offered a helpful maxim. Dr. Ginott said children need to have a voice and, when appropriate, a choice. In other words, expressing thoughts and feelings is important for children. But as adults, we are still responsible for their welfare. For example, an eight-year-old child is free to tell us he doesn’t like doing homework, participating in P.E., or his tutoring, and we can sympathize, citing our own lack of enthusiasm for doing the things “we had to do” growing up. But none of these are elective activities like playing baseball or taking music.

After acknowledging a child’sfeelings about doingsomething she doesn’t like, we can offer scaled-down choices (“I know you’d rather be playing outside than doing homework. Do you want to work with me on your assignment now or after dinner?”). Many of the power struggles occur because we haven’t providedclarity about what choices a child actually has. For example, we often tack the word “okay” on the end of requests that don’t really involve a choice. “It’s time to go to school, okay?” It’s frustrating to realize after asking “okay?” that there really isn’t anotheroption.It’s even harder to backtrack when we lay down edicts that we can’t enforce —“You need to eat everything on your plate” or “Go to sleep right now.”

Most importantly, we need to reflect on what choices a child is ready to make. We’ve all made silly or poor choices in our lives and learn by living with the consequences. For example, a child who chooses not to clean up after herself in preschool simply can’t play in that area later that day.

As adults we protect children’s well being by setting appropriate limits. Stopping to reflect about the good choices children make is a crucial part of the process. “How did it work out choosing to stay at the birthday party when you were so tired?” “What would you do next time?” Examining little choices helps build the skill to make more important decisions.

Dilemmas about what choices to allow children is often thought of as a tough parenting issue

because we want to get them to comply. However, having the support to make choices boosts responsibility and consciousness of others. Look for books on decision making with children and chat with parents who talk with their children effectively about decisions. Praise your child for struggling with emotional reactions and difficulties with self-control. Think back to choices you made as a young person. What kinds of coaching or limit setting would have helped you? We’re all learners when it comes to making life choices. It’s a topic worthy of fruitful discussion.

Susan Isaacs Kohl, is director of the White Pony preschool in Lafayette. She is the author of The Best Things Parents Do (Conari 2004) and four other books and numerous articles for parents.


Children’s Perspectives on Spanking

It seems especially refreshing for children to live in a place and a time when children would assume a teacher would never physically punish them and feel safe to ask questions so openly.

Being with Other People’s Children

In the past, adults felt free to discipline other people’s children when they misbehaved. We live in more enlightened times when people want to establish a trusting relationship with children even when that involves setting limits.

Rethinking Birthdays

Birthday parties today tend to loom large in children’s fantasies months ahead of the event. “I’m going to have a Batman party,” a four-year-old will announce right after his last birthday celebration.

Look for Upliftment

In times past, parents looked to experts like Dr. Spock or Haim Ginott to inspire them with new ways to relate to children. Today parents who go online or read widely about childrearing can glean insights but also easily feel overwhelmed.

Playdates Require Sensible Guidelines

We want to ensure that parents use sensible guidelines when allowing their child to visit someone else’s home. We share ideas about this subject because the notion of children needing to have playdates is relatively recent.

Guiding Play Away From Aggression

Batman swoops in, shocking his enemies and knocking them ferociously to the ground. This scene sizzles on screen. However, played out by four-year-old boys eager to feel powerful, it quickly ends in tears.