It’s one of the hardest questions any of us can imagine asking someone we love—but according to Harvard psychologist Dr. Matthew Nock, it’s also one of the most important.
In his interview on The On Purpose Podcast with Jay Shetty, Dr. Nock shared decades of research showing that asking about suicide does not increase suicidal thoughts or behaviors. In fact, it can be life-saving.
“Talking about suicide doesn’t make people suicidal,” Dr. Nock explained. “It opens a door. It tells them they can come to you when they’re in pain.”
Why Asking the Question Matters
Every year, suicide takes nearly a million lives worldwide—more than war or homicide combined. Yet most people who attempt suicide don’t actually want to die.
“Ninety percent of people who try to kill themselves say they didn’t want to die per se,” says Dr. Nock. “They wanted to escape what felt like intolerable pain.”
That’s why connection matters so deeply. Two-thirds of people who die by suicide told someone beforehand. But too often, those comments—jokes, offhand remarks, or cries for help—get brushed aside because friends and family don’t know how to respond.
The #1 Life-Saving Question
Dr. Nock trains clinicians and parents alike to use one clear, compassionate question:
“Are things so bad that you’ve thought about suicide?”
This simple sentence creates safety and permission for honesty. It’s calm, direct, and nonjudgmental. He emphasizes asking the question without panic or shame—and following up with presence and support.
If someone says yes, the next steps are equally important. Nock offers a simple acronym:
A.I.R. — Ask. Initiate. Refer.
- A – Ask the question. Don’t avoid it out of fear.
- I – Initiate a conversation or support. Stay with the person, listen, and express care.
- R – Refer for help. Contact a therapist, doctor, or the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline.
“I tell people, don’t promise to keep it a secret,” says Nock. “Tell them, ‘I care about you too much not to get you help.’”
Scroll to continue
More from Mama
Subscribe
What Every Parent Should Know
Suicidal thoughts can start younger than most parents realize. Nock says he began talking to his own children about suicide around age 10.
“Kids today face enormous pressures,” he says. “If we can talk about fires and earthquakes, we can talk about suicidal thoughts. Fifteen percent of people will experience them at some point.”
Having these conversations doesn’t plant the idea—it helps kids know that their feelings can be shared safely.
How to Respond If They Say “No”
Even if someone denies suicidal thoughts, the act of asking builds trust. It communicates:
“You can always come to me if that changes.”
Dr. Nock explains that in his research, 78% of people who die by suicide had previously denied suicidal thoughts in their final communications. That means the door must stay open—without judgment, stigma, or silence.
What to Do Next
If you’re worried about someone you love:
- Keep checking in. One question isn’t the end—it’s the beginning.
- Offer resources. In the U.S., call or text 988 for the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline.
- Share space. Just being with someone in their pain can make a difference.
- Connect them to help. Encourage therapy, school counselors, or support groups through AFSP.org.
Breaking the Silence
Suicide is still surrounded by stigma—but silence is deadly.
“Closing our eyes to it doesn’t make it go away,” says Jay Shetty. “Talking about it saves lives.”
Dr. Nock believes that just as we teach fire drills in school, we should also teach emotional safety plans—because everyone deserves to know what to do when life feels unbearable.
If You or Someone You Know Is in Crisis
You are not alone.
Call or text 988 (U.S.) for free, confidential support 24/7.
If you’re outside the U.S., find international hotlines at [findahelpline.com], or reach out to a trusted friend, teacher, or counselor.
It’s About Courage
The #1 life-saving question isn’t about having the perfect words.
It’s about having the courage to ask.
Because one honest question can open a door—and sometimes, that’s all it takes to save a life.
More on TodaysMama.com
Teen Stress, Depression, and Suicide on the Rise
Leave a Reply